Make These 10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts & Steal Game Day Cheers!

Yo.  L1? What is that?  Superbowl L1 that is…..I thought that ‘L1’ was one of the bones that I hurt in my back a few years back. Turns out it is the call sign for this year’s Superbowl 51.  Well, I guess I should be tuning into the game play rather than loading up recipe counts.  Truth is, nerds always prevail, even on Superbowl L1.

10-Minute Super Bowl DessertsIn a few days, family and friends will cram into our cozy living room, stacking extra chairs and crowding in around the couch. Standing room only.  There will be kids tearing through the house, pounding our wood floors and running outside to play quarterback. Super Bowl Sunday is hectic around here, so I like to make sure we have tons and tons of food on hand. For desserts this year, I went with these amazingly easy, 10-minute Super Bowl desserts.

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts

In addition to our annual pulled pork sandwiches and queso fundido, I always try to offer a dessert that satisfies the big kids as well as the little ones.  This year, I am busting out with an easy-peasy chocolate pudding and an ice cream sandwich hack on the side.  The ice cream sandwich doesn’t require any baking at all, so if time is short, go for the ice cream sandwich, but if you have even a few minutes, you can whip up this pudding no problem!  It was one of the first things I learned while I was in pastry school at The New School of Cooking.

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts

10-Minute Pudding How To

To make short-work of this chocolate pudding, separate your ingredients into 3 groups:

  1. Saucepan Liquids (milk/sugar/chocolate)
  2. Mixing Bowl Ingredients (eggs/cornstarch/cream)
  3. Finishing Ingredients (butter/vanilla)

10-Minute Super Bowl DessertsIn the saucepan, gently heat the milk and sugar in a non-reactive pot until warm.  Then, add chocolate and melt into the milk until scalding.

In a separate mixing bowl, whisk the eggs, cream, and cornstarch to a smooth consistency.

Add the scalded chocolate milk to your eggs/cream/cornstarch mixture a little bit at a time. If you add it too quickly, the hot chocolate will cook your eggs and give your pudding a funny consistency, so take your time. The goal is to raise the temperature of the eggs without actually cooking them.

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts

Once you’ve got it all mixed up, pour the whole batch back into the saucepan and continue to cook it on the stovetop, stirring constantly.

You’ll know you’re just about done when you get these luscious bubbles.

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts

Add in the butter and vanilla to finish, give it a few final stirs, and remove from the stovetop.  Voila!

While it’s still piping hot, cover it with saran wrap, making sure that the plastic is touching the pudding so that you don’t get a skin, and then place it in the refrigerator until chilled.

To get that Super Bowl look, prep a bunch of votive glasses with white tape and pipe in the pudding using a piping bag or a ziplock.

Top them off with some fun paper pennants.  I made these ones myself  using templates from some of my favorite bloggers: Game Day Paper Chain (The Centsible Life), and Cupcake Toppers How To, (Sarah Hearts). Kelly at the Centsible Life helps women live happier, healthier, and wealthier lives. Sarah from SarahHearts helps women be creative with awesome DIY ideas including a sampling of how to build easy cupcake toppers.

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts

Love these game day pudding winners!  I bought some of these fun props such as the milk bottles at Sweet Lulu, an incredible online baking store and those fun footballs at Party City.

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts

Ice Cream Sandwich Hack

Second in our 10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts line-up is this football ice cream sandwich. Too cute! Right?  And so easy too.  You can buy white frosting or make your own royal icing.  Just follow these step-by-step photos, and you’ll be all set for some game day fun.

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts

Start by drawing some game plays onto your ice cream sticks.  I wanted to add hearts, but my husband insisted that the NFL doesn’t use hearts in their game day attack. Fine.  


I used a Whole Foods 365 Ice Cream Sandwich Bar. I’m sure the available brands will vary, depending on where you’re shopping, but if you’re not sure which to buy, check out this post by TheKitchn where they compared 7 different brands. Lots of choices people!

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts

DIY Paper Fun

It’s not a party without decorations.

To save a bit of money, I went DIY on this one, and I couldn’t have been happier with the results!  A few bright green paper chains and game day pennants really made the house feel festive. Game on!

Here’s a behind-the-scenes look at how it all come together.

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts


Photos by: Maria Hedrick Photography

10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts
10-Minute Super Bowl Desserts

Chocolate Pudding

By TheSweetNerd  

January 31, 2017

  • Prep: 5 mins


5 tablespoons sugar

4 ounces bittersweet chocolate

1 1/3 cup milk

2 tablespoons cornstarch

1 egg yolk

2 tablespoons heavy cream

1/2 ounces butter

1/2 teaspoon vanilla


1Saucepan: Gently heat the milk and sugar in a non-reactive pot until warm. Then, add chocolate and melt into the milk until scalding.

2Separate Mixing Bowl: Whisk egg yolk, cornstarch and heavy cream. Temper (adding a hot liquid into an egg mixture) the scalding saucepan mixture into the cornstarch, yolk, and cream in a slow steady stream. The trick here is to whisk furiously as the hot liquid hits the egg mixture so it doesn't cook. It is easy, just keep your whisk moving and pour all of the mixture slowly.

3Then immediately, pour back into the pot and cook until thick.

4Finish with vanilla and butter then strain.

5Refrigerate for an optimal 6 hours.

The New School of Cooking: Chocolate Pudding


Superbowl Pudding


  • Anna Ehrlich
    7 years ago

    Thanks Cindy for these quick and fun desserts for Super Bowl. Looking forward to trying them!

  • Bee
    7 years ago

    The kid in me is excited to make these for my sports gang! Super and simple-thanks!

  • Mary Arnold
    7 years ago

    Can’t wait to try these recipes for my Super Bowl party!
    Thanks sweet nerds!

    • Cindy "TheSweetNerd" Rodriguez
      7 years ago

      Hope you do Mary, I think you will love it. Easy and fast.

  • Karen Grant-Selma
    7 years ago

    This does look super easy. If I use similar sized votive holders, how many servings will I end up with?

    • Cindy "TheSweetNerd" Rodriguez
      7 years ago

      I doubled the recipe and made a dozen! You can extend the recipe by adding whipped cream in the middle and use less chocolate pudding for each votive depending on your crowd! Cheers momma.

  • Super recipe, Cindy! Easy and delicious. Keep up the good work.

    • Cindy "TheSweetNerd" Rodriguez
      7 years ago

      Thanks Agnes! So appreciate the compliment and the inspirational words. Cheers.

  • Kendall
    7 years ago

    You have such an eye for the whole spread. The big picture is never left out. Love the pudding and the cute extra ice cream sandwich ‘hack!’

    • Cindy "TheSweetNerd" Rodriguez
      7 years ago

      That ice cream hack was a hit on Superbowl Day. Hope you tried it. Thanks Kendall!

Related Posts